Publisher: Activision Inc.

Developer: Spark

Category: Action

Release Dates

N Amer - 11/16/2004

Intl - 11/16/2004

Official Game Website

    Also available on:
  • PS2
  • XB



Call of Duty: Finest Hour Review

Bookmark and Share Share Glink It Glink It

This certainly has been a year for war games seeing as how we’ve been taken into the Pacific Theatre in Medal of Honor: Rising Sun to the steaming jungles of Vietnam with Men of Valor. Yet somehow we keep returning to the year the world went to war because not only did American troops answer the call of duty but also so did our allies - Russia and the UK. Call of Duty: Finest Hour gives us a chance to see the war through the eyes of American GIs but also through other Allied heroes that stood up against the forces of the crooked cross. Is this a World War II first-person shooter the finest hour on the GameCube?

Call of Duty doesn’t weave one tale by following a single soldier throughout his campaign, rather - and much unlike the PC original - it follows multiple Allied soldiers during three very different campaigns in the Eastern, Western and North African front. You’ll start by seeing the war through different Russians soldiers as they attempt to take back Stalingrad, then follow a group of British soldiers in Africa as they attempt to push back the Nazis and finally follow American soldiers in Belgium. While it sounds great to see the war through different characters, you’ll hardly get a chance to get to know them better as each soldier has an interesting background.

As a result, you’ll spend less time worrying about your character and those around him (or, in the Russian campaign, her) and concentrate on shooting Nazis. At the start of the game you assume the role of Alexander Sokovo as the Russians enter the charred remains of the Red Square during the most brutal campaign of Stalingrad. You’ll quickly encounter and then assume the role of Tanya, a sniper, and follow the campaign to its end when the story shifts to the British PPA Commando unit as they attempt to invade a North Africa overrun by German forces. You’ll find yourself shooting enemy soldiers on the back of a moving jeep. In Belgium, you’ll be able to not only escort a tank but also go behind the wheel and drive into the frontlines.

Control-wise, the game feels right at home on the GameCube due to the game’s basic first-person shooter elements. You can aim down the sights with the L button for more precise shooting and even use your firearm as a melee weapon for when the enemy is up close and personal. Your arsenal list is true to the time period but thanks the different viewpoints; you’ll be using Russian, British and standard issue American firearms. If you’re not happy with your Tommy gun, you can always pick up an enemy firearm out on the battlefield. This is great for those who prefer the German stick grenade to the usual fragmentation grenades used by the Allied troops. You’ll be happy to have a comrade or two by your side in many of the missions since they do a good job of covering you ... but they can also be killed.

Here’s some good news, bad news. The good news is that the enemy AI can be really smart to the point that they’ll be ducking for cover and try to find ways of outflanking you. You’ll encounter many a time when the enemy will move to a better spot when they’ve lost sight of you. The bad news is that the enemy AI can also be pretty darn dumb. They’ll run into your line of fire if there isn’t any place to take cover and the enemy will occasionally run right past you if you’re moving too quickly. The levels, while well conceived, have far too many scripted events that completely shatter the fun. Man a mounted gun and like moths to a flame you’ll get Nazis come out of seemingly nowhere and into the line of fire. It’s far too easy to memorize enemy attacks if you die because nothing in their formation or action ever changes. However, unlike Medal of Honor: Rising Sun, the heavily scripted moments don’t take away from the game’s overall fun factor.

While not graphically spectacular, it’s hard not to love a game with plenty of visual effects that depict war so frighteningly gritty. Whether you’re defending the shattered and darkened remains of the Red Square or traveling across the scorching-dry African dunes, the environments are done well enough to immerse you into each campaign. The character models are rendered realistically enough and they have actual facial details that add more to the realism factor (e.g. they scowl when they’re angry and wince when they’re shot). They also move naturally and there are a decent variety of death animations. Still it’s the visual effects that make the graphics shine and the explosions will not fail to impress.

Much like Frontline and Rising Sun, Call of Duty possesses a soundtrack that’s not only gorgeous, sweeping and dramatic, but it also has a few musical sequences that don’t go hand-in-hand with your current situation. It’s like playing circus music during a funeral . . . they just don’t go together, right? Still these instances are few and this really isn’t such a major complaint seeing at the score makes the game feel like you’re watching an epic war film. The voice acting is pretty great with narration by Dennis Haysbert (of TV’s 24) and Brian Johnson (you know, the lead singer of AC/DC) as a character in the game. The sound effects really rock so be sure to turn up the volume.

Call of Duty: Finest Hour has all the makings of an amazing first-person shooter but despite some really well designed levels, the game seems to stick to the scripted moments too faithfully. This doesn’t mean the game is boring - it’s far from it, really - it just means that there are very few surprises in this one. Still, fans of the genre will have a great time with this one so pick it up if you like a decent war game.

Review Scoring Details for Call of Duty: Finest Hour

Gameplay: 7.5
The heavily scripted moments make this your average World War II first-person shooter with very few tricks or surprises up its sleeve. Still, this doesn’t mean you won’t have fun and thanks to great controls, this game feels right at home with the GameCube. There is also some really cool and extreme fun sniper missions. Hmm, but no multiplayer mode? Activision, are you purposely trying to make this girl cry?

Graphics: 8.0
Come for the nicely rendered characters with wonderfully realistic facial expressions and stay for the powerful depictions of war in all its explosive and bullet-riddled glory. The backgrounds are great, especially the African desert, and the effects are done just right.

Sound: 8.5
The voice acting is sparse and you’ll wish you there’s more chatter coming from the comrades that accompany you but at least the acting is perfect. There’s a score and it’s magnificently sweeping, dramatic, beautiful and often times - like Medal of Honor: Frontline - it occasionally feels out of place in some segments of the game. It’s the sound effects that put us in the war so if you have a great sound system hooked up, crank up the volume on this baby.

Difficulty: Medium
A pretty straightforward first-person shooter like this one isn’t too challenging since there are many scripted events that don’t change the formation of the enemy at all. If you were killed in action, you’ll be taken back to the start of the checkpoint but now you’ll know exactly where the enemies will come out. The enemy AI is both smart and boy-are-you-Nazis-dumb.

Concept: 7.0
Seeing the war through the eyes of various Allied soldiers is not a bad concept at all. In fact, it could have been brilliant only the constant changing of characters doesn’t give use a chance to appreciate them. There are cool levels here and a chance to use a variety of weapons throughout each campaign. We can even drive a tank. And is it me or does the soldier on the box cover look like hunky actor Russell Crowe?

Overall: 7.5
While not the finest of hours, Call of Duty: Finest Hour is still a fun first-person shooter on the GameCube. The action can sometimes be too scripted and some levels lack that intensity of the PC original, but we’re still looking at a fun time at the frontlines. If you’re a fan of the Medal of Honor series, pick this one up. 

 

 

 



Call of Duty: Finest Hour Comments (0)



GameZone Review Detail

Gameplay7.5
Graphics8
Sound8.5
DifficultyMedium
Concept7
Overall7.5

7.5

GZ Rating

While not the finest of hours, Call of Duty: Finest Hour is still a fun first-person shooter on the GameCube

Reviewer: Natalie Romano

Review Date: 12/06/2004


ESRB Rating

Teen
Blood
Violence

Industry Critic Reviews